DishShuffle Logo
Dish Shuffle
HomeSmart PantryRecipesCollectionsBlog
Sign In
Sign In
HomeSmart Pantry
Surprise Me
RecipesCollections
Dish Shuffle Logo
Dish Shuffle

Discover delicious meals from around the world.

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Surprise Me
  • Browse Recipes
  • Favorites
  • Blog
  • FAQ

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 Dish Shuffle All rights reserved..

  1. Home
  2. Browse Recipes
  3. Caprese-Style Stuffed Tomatoes with Balsamic Reduction
Mediterraneanside dishMediterraneanItalianEuropeanside dish
646 kcal

Caprese-Style Stuffed Tomatoes with Balsamic Reduction

Caprese-Style Stuffed Tomatoes with Balsamic Reduction
👨‍🍳

💡Chef's Note

“Discover how to make the perfect Caprese-Style Stuffed Tomatoes with Balsamic Reduction. This Mediterranean classic is part of our side dish collection and is sure to impress your family and friends with its delicious flavors.”

Ingredients

  • balsamic vinegar
    balsamic vinegar1 c
  • vine ripened tomatoes
    vine ripened tomatoes8
  • sugar
    sugar1.5 t
  • kosher salt & pepper
    kosher salt & pepper4 servings
  • olive oil
    olive oil4 T
  • couscous
    couscous1 c
  • garlic
    garlic2 cloves
  • pepper flakes
    pepper flakes0.125 t
  • lemon juice
    lemon juice1 T
  • basil
    basil1 c
  • parmesan cheese
    parmesan cheese0.75 c
  • mozzarella cheese
    mozzarella cheese8 oz
🛒

Shop Ingredients

Get these items delivered by Amazon Fresh

balsamic vinegarBuy on Amazon ↗vine ripened tomatoesBuy on Amazon ↗sugarBuy on Amazon ↗kosher salt & pepperBuy on Amazon ↗olive oilBuy on Amazon ↗couscousBuy on Amazon ↗garlicBuy on Amazon ↗pepper flakesBuy on Amazon ↗lemon juiceBuy on Amazon ↗basilBuy on Amazon ↗parmesan cheeseBuy on Amazon ↗mozzarella cheeseBuy on Amazon ↗

*Links open in Amazon Fresh/Grocery. We may earn a commission.

Nutrition Facts

Calories646kcal
Protein26g
Carbs60g
Fat33g

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.

Instructions

In a small sauce pan, bring balsamic vinegar to a simmer over medium high heat, simmer until the vinegar is reduced to 1/4 c.

Set aside to cool.

Preheat oven to 375 degrees f.

Slice the top 1/2-inch off of each tomato (reserve tops) and using a sharp spoon or a melon baller (I used an inexpensive aluminum tablespoon-sized measuring spoon) scoop out the cores and seeds from the tomatoes into a fine mesh strainer set over a bowl to catch the juices.

Using your hands, break up and squeeze the pulp from the tomatoes to extract as much liquid as possible.

Reserve 2/3 c.

of the tomato juice (if needed add enough water to the juices to equal the 2/3 c.).

In a small bowl combine the sugar and 1 1/2 t.

kosher salt and sprinkle evenly inside the tomatoes.

Lay the tomatoes cut-side down on a plate and set aside for 30 minutes.

Heat 2 T.

olive oil in a medium saucepan over medium heat until the oil is shimmering.

Add the couscous and cook, stirring constantly until the couscous is coated in the oil and beginning to brown, about 2-3 minutes.

Add the garlic and pepper flakes, stir until evenly dispersed and fragrant.

Add the reserved tomato juice and remove from the heat, cover and let sit until the couscous is rehydrated, about 7 minutes.

Gently fluff with a fork, stir in the lemon juice, basil and 3/4 c.

Parmesan.

Season with salt & pepper to taste.

Then fold in the diced mozzarella.

After the tomatoes have sat for 30 minutes, blot the insides of the tomatoes dry with paper towels.

Sprinkle the cavities lightly with salt & pepper.

Fill the tomatoes with the stuffing.

Drizzle the remaining 2 T.

olive oil in a 13x9-inch baking dish.

Add the tomatoes to the baking dish.

Combine the 1/2 c.

shredded mozzarella and the remaining 2 T.

Parmesan, sprinkle over the tops of the tomatoes.

Season the reserved tomato tops with salt & pepper and place in the empty spaces in the baking dish.

Bake until the tomatoes are softened but still hold their shape and the cheese on top is spotty-brown, 20-25 minutes.

Serve the tomatoes, drizzled with the balsamic reduction.

❤️

Love This Recipe?

Save it to your favorites and never lose it!

or
🔪

Recommended Kitchen Gear

Slow Cooker

Slow Cooker

Shop on Amazon ↗
Baking Sheet

Baking Sheet

Shop on Amazon ↗
Kitchen Scale

Kitchen Scale

Shop on Amazon ↗

*As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

You Might Also Like

Pasta With Cream Sauce and Mushrooms
side dish

Pasta With Cream Sauce and Mushrooms

45m4 servings558 kcal
You’ll Flip for These Skinny Frozen S’mores, No Campfire Needed
side dish

You’ll Flip for These Skinny Frozen S’mores, No Campfire Needed

45m1 servings87 kcal
Traditional Panzanella
Mediterraneanside dish

Traditional Panzanella

45m6 servings356 kcal

Explore More on Our Blog

Learn tips, tricks, and kitchen secrets related to this dish.

View All Articles
7 No-Fail Christmas Side Dishes You Can Prep This Weekend
Quick & Easy
Dec 13, 2025•20 min read

7 No-Fail Christmas Side Dishes You Can Prep This Weekend

Simplify your holiday cooking with these 7 no-fail Christmas side dishes that you can prepare in advance. From casseroles to roasted veggies, these recipes are designed to minimize stress and maximize flavor.

Read Post
Mediterranean Flavors: A Journey Through Greek and Turkish Cooking
Cuisine Exploration
May 6, 2024•9 min read

Mediterranean Flavors: A Journey Through Greek and Turkish Cooking

From Meze platters to grilled kebabs, explore the shared culinary heritage of Greece and Turkey.

Read Post
Exploring Italian Cuisine: Beyond Pasta and Pizza
Cuisine Exploration
Apr 15, 2024•11 min read

Exploring Italian Cuisine: Beyond Pasta and Pizza

Think you know Italian food? Think again. Discover the regional diversity of Italy's 20 regions, from Risotto in Milan to Caponata in Sicily.

Read Post